Bobbie vs Similac (2026): Premium Organic vs America's Top Formula
Bobbie's clean organic formula versus Similac 360's HMO-powered lineup. Which fits your baby?
Quick Answer
Bobbie is USDA organic with lactose-only carbs and no palm oil. Similac 360 Total Care has 5 HMOs (immune support) and no palm oil either — but isn't organic. Similac is cheaper ($28 vs $34) and available everywhere. Bobbie wins on organic/clean label; Similac wins on HMO count and price.
Key Takeaways
- Bobbie: USDA organic, lactose-only carbs, no palm oil — $34/can, limited retail
- Similac 360 Total Care: 5 HMOs for immune support, no palm oil, not organic — $28, everywhere
- Bobbie wins on organic certification and clean label
- Similac wins on HMO count, price, and availability
- Both avoid palm oil — a tie on that front
- Bobbie Gentle vs Similac Sensitive: Bobbie stays organic; Similac Sensitive is lactose-free
📋 Affiliate Disclosure: TeachToddler.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us continue providing free, expert parenting content. We only recommend products we genuinely believe in. Learn more
Bobbie Organic
USDA Organic
Lactose Only
Similac 360 Total Care
5 HMOs
Palm Oil Free
Where to Buy: Best Prices
Bobbie Organic Infant Formula
- USDA organic
- Lactose-only carbs
- No palm oil
- Higher price
- Limited retail
Similac 360 Total Care Infant Formula
- 5 HMOs
- No palm oil
- Widely available
- Not organic
- Corn syrup solids
Comparison Table
| Feature | Bobbie Organic | Similac 360 Total Care | Bobbie Gentle | Similac Sensitive |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Organic | Yes | No | Yes | No |
| HMOs | No | 5 HMOs | No | No |
| Carb Source | Lactose only | Corn syrup solids | Lactose + rice starch | Corn syrup solids |
| Palm Oil | No | No | No | No |
| DHA Source | Algae | Fish oil | Algae | Fish oil |
| Price | ~$34 | ~$28 | ~$34 | ~$32 |
| Availability | Online (Bobbie, Amazon) | Walmart, Target, CVS, Amazon | Online | Everywhere |
Organic vs Non-Organic
Bobbie is USDA organic certified: milk from organic farms, no synthetic pesticides, organic ingredient standards. Similac 360 Total Care is conventional. If organic matters, Bobbie is the only option. Similac focuses on functional ingredients (HMOs) rather than organic certification.
HMO Content Comparison
Similac 360 Total Care contains 5 HMOs (human milk oligosaccharides) — 2'-FL, 3-FL, 3'-SL, 6'-SL, and LNnT — designed to support immune health and gut microbiome, similar to breast milk. Bobbie does not add HMOs. For parents who want immune-support ingredients beyond basic nutrition, Similac 360 has the edge.
Clean Label Showdown
Both avoid palm oil. Bobbie uses lactose only as the carb source (closest to breast milk). Similac 360 uses corn syrup solids. Bobbie wins on carb quality and organic certification. Similac wins on HMO count. Neither uses palm oil — a tie on fat blend quality.
Price and Where to Buy
Bobbie costs about $34 per can, sold via Bobbie.com and Amazon. Similac 360 Total Care runs ~$28 at Walmart, Target, Amazon, and drugstores. Similac is cheaper and far more widely available. Bobbie is primarily a direct-to-consumer and Amazon brand.
Gentle Versions Compared
Bobbie Gentle uses partially hydrolyzed protein and rice starch — still USDA organic, no palm oil. Similac Sensitive is fully lactose-free with milk protein isolate and no palm oil. For lactose intolerance, Similac Sensitive is the better choice. For organic + gentle digestion, Bobbie Gentle.
Final Verdict
- Choose Bobbie if: You want USDA organic, lactose-only carbs, and a clean label — and budget allows.
- Choose Similac 360 if: You want 5 HMOs for immune support, lower price, and availability at any store.
- Bottom line: Bobbie wins on organic and clean ingredients; Similac wins on HMOs, price, and convenience.
More Formula Comparisons
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Bobbie better than Similac?
It depends. Bobbie is better if you want USDA organic, lactose-only carbs, and a clean label without palm oil. Similac 360 Total Care is better if you want 5 HMOs for immune support, lower price ($28 vs $34), and widespread availability. Neither is 'better' for everyone — it's a trade-off between organic/clean and HMOs/price.
Does Similac 360 have palm oil?
No. Similac 360 Total Care uses a palm-oil-free fat blend, similar to Bobbie. Both formulas avoid palm oil, which can cause firmer stools. This is a point of parity between the two.
Is Bobbie formula organic?
Yes. Bobbie is USDA organic certified. Similac 360 Total Care is conventional (non-organic). If organic certification is important to you, Bobbie is the only option between these two.
Which has more HMOs Bobbie or Similac?
Similac 360 Total Care has 5 HMOs (human milk oligosaccharides), which support immune health and gut microbiome. Bobbie does not add HMOs. Similac wins on HMO content for immune support.
Can I find Bobbie at Target?
Bobbie is sold primarily through Bobbie.com and Amazon. It is not currently available at Target, Walmart, or most traditional retailers. Similac 360 is widely available at Target, Walmart, CVS, and grocery stores.
Which is easier on baby's stomach?
Both use cow's milk and are generally well-tolerated. Bobbie's lactose-only carbs and no palm oil may suit some babies better. Similac Sensitive (gentle version) is fully lactose-free for sensitive tummies. For typical babies, either can work; for lactose intolerance, Similac Sensitive.
TeachToddler Editorial Team
Related Reading
Bobbie vs Kendamil
Organic formula brands compared head-to-head.
12 min readBobbie vs Enfamil
Organic newcomer vs formula giant.
12 min readSimilac vs Enfamil: Complete Brand Comparison
Full breakdown of both brands across all product lines.
14 min readBest Baby Formula Guide
Complete guide to choosing the right formula.
14 min read