How to Wean a Toddler Off the Pacifier: When to Start and Methods That Work
Pacifiers are a real help in the baby months, but most families start thinking about giving them up somewhere between the first and third birthday. Here is what pediatricians and pediatric dentists say about timing, the research on ears, teeth and speech, and step-by-step plans for gradual, cold-turkey and bedtime weaning.
What parents should know
- In the first year, pacifiers have real benefits: the AAP recommends offering one at nap time and bedtime because it lowers the risk of SIDS.
- After the first birthday the balance shifts. The AAPD links use after 12 months with more ear infections and use beyond 18 months with open bite and crossbite.
- In a Finnish trial at well-baby clinics, counseling parents to limit pacifiers cut continuous use by 21% and ear infections by 29%.
- Gradual weaning (sleep-only first, then none) and a planned "cold turkey" day both work; choose the one that fits your child's temperament and your family's schedule.
- Positive approaches work better than criticism or restraint, which the AAPD warns can lead to power struggles that make the habit last longer.
- Do not cut holes in pacifiers, tie them to cribs or clothing with cords, or coat them in honey. Each carries a safety risk.
Why pacifiers help babies, and why the advice changes for toddlers
Babies are born with a strong need to suck, and a pacifier can satisfy the part of that need that feeding does not. In the newborn months it has proven benefits. The American Academy of Pediatrics' 2022 safe sleep recommendations list pacifier use at sleep time as one of the ways to reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), alongside back sleeping and a firm, flat sleep surface. HealthyChildren.org suggests offering a pacifier at nap time and bedtime, and waiting about 3 to 4 weeks if you are breastfeeding, until feeding is going well.
The AAPD's Policy on Pacifiers adds other benefits: comfort and self-soothing, pain relief during minor procedures, help for premature babies developing the sucking reflex, and a lower chance of a thumb or finger habit later. That last point matters, because a pacifier can be taken away and a thumb cannot.
After the first year, though, the AAP's safe sleep guidance no longer applies in the same way, because it is written for infants, and the downsides become more relevant. By the toddler years, a pacifier has usually become a comfort tool for falling asleep, handling big feelings or getting through boring moments, much like a favorite blanket. That is completely normal, and it is also why weaning is more about replacing comfort than about breaking a "bad habit."
When to wean: what the experts actually say
Different organizations frame the timeline slightly differently, but none of them says a pacifier must disappear on the first birthday. Together, they describe a window between roughly 12 months and 3 years in which to gradually cut back and stop.
Is there such a thing as too early?
Possibly. The AAPD notes that allowing the habit to continue beyond about 14 months may help prevent a persistent finger habit. That is based on a Japanese study of 555 children aged 36 to 47 months, which found that children whose pacifier use was stopped before 14 months had much higher odds of persistent finger sucking (odds ratio 8.62). It was a questionnaire-based, cross-sectional study, so it cannot prove cause and effect, but it is a useful reminder that taking the pacifier away from a young child who still has a strong need to suck can simply move the habit to a thumb.
A practical reading of all this: for most families, the sweet spot is to start cutting back after the first birthday, aim for sleep-only use by around 18 months, and have the pacifier gone well before age 3.
| Age | What the guidance says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 0 to 12 months | Offer a pacifier at nap time and bedtime to lower SIDS risk. Do not force it if your baby refuses. | AAP safe sleep recommendations (2022); HealthyChildren.org |
| After 12 months | Pacifier use can increase the risk of acute otitis media (middle ear infections). Reducing or stopping use in the second half of the first year may lower ear infections. | AAPD Policy on Pacifiers |
| Around 18 months | Use beyond 18 months can influence the developing mouth and jaws, leading to anterior open bite, posterior crossbite and Class II bite problems. Limiting use when the canine teeth come in (about 18 months) has been recommended. | AAPD Policy on Pacifiers |
| 2 to 4 years | Strong sucking on a pacifier, thumb or fingers beyond 2 to 4 years may affect the shape of the mouth or how the teeth line up. | HealthyChildren.org (AAP) |
| By 36 months | The AAPD encourages discontinuing non-nutritive sucking habits by 36 months of age. Open bite from a pacifier tends to improve if the pacifier is stopped before age 3. | AAPD Policy on Pacifiers |
What the research says about ears, teeth and speech
Ear infections
The link between pacifiers and ear infections is one of the better-studied effects. In a Finnish study of 845 children in day care, pacifier use raised the yearly rate of acute ear infections from 3.6 to 5.4 episodes in children under 2, and from 1.9 to 2.7 in 2- to 3-year-olds. A follow-up trial at 14 well-baby clinics found that when nurses counseled parents to limit pacifiers, continuous use at 7 to 18 months fell by 21% and ear infections were 29% lower than at control clinics. Children who did not use a pacifier continuously had 33% fewer episodes. An older meta-analysis put the added risk from pacifier use at about 24% (risk ratio 1.24).
Notably, the Finnish researchers found that limiting the pacifier to the moments when a child was falling asleep was enough to prevent many ear infections. If your toddler gets frequent ear infections, that is a good reason to move to sleep-only use soon. Our guide to toddler ear infection signs explains what to watch for.
Teeth and bite
The AAPD policy summarizes many studies showing that children who use a pacifier for 36 months or longer have a significantly higher rate of anterior open bite, where the front teeth do not meet. Longer use is also linked with posterior crossbite, where the upper back teeth sit inside the lower ones. Duration seems to matter more than how often a child sucks each day.
The encouraging news is that pacifier-related open bite tends to improve once the pacifier is stopped before about age 3. So-called orthodontic pacifiers may cause somewhat less open bite than conventional shapes, but the AAPD notes that reviews have not found enough evidence to say they prevent bite problems, and no pacifier shape matched the improvement seen when children stopped using one. If you are still in the pacifier phase, our roundup of orthodontic pacifiers explains the differences.
Speech
Many parents worry that a pacifier will delay talking. The evidence here is thinner than you might expect. The AAPD says evidence linking pacifiers to speech delay is limited. A 2021 UK study of 100 children aged 24 to 61 months found most speech measures were not linked to pacifier use at all, although more frequent daytime use was associated with more atypical speech errors. Night-time use and total duration were not.
The practical takeaway is simple: a pacifier in the mouth all day makes it harder to babble, talk and practice sounds, so keeping it for sleep is a sensible first step. If you have concerns about your toddler's talking, see our guide to speech delay in toddlers and talk with your pediatrician.
Signs your toddler is ready (and times to wait)
Readiness is partly about age and partly about timing in your family's life. A toddler who already goes long stretches without the pacifier, forgets about it while playing, or can understand a simple explanation is usually ready for a plan.
- Good signs: your child mostly wants the pacifier only at sleep times, can be distracted from it, has another comfort object, or is old enough (often around 2 and up) to take part in a goodbye ritual.
- Reasons to move sooner: frequent ear infections, the pacifier is in the mouth most of the day and getting in the way of talking, or your dentist sees changes in the bite.
- Times to wait a few weeks: a new sibling, starting daycare, moving house, a recent illness, travel or a sleep regression. Big changes make toddlers lean harder on comfort habits.
Method 1: Gradual weaning (best for most toddlers)
Gradual weaning follows the approach the Finnish researchers used: shrink the pacifier's role to falling asleep, then remove it entirely. It usually takes a few weeks and tends to cause fewer tears for younger toddlers.
Step 1: Make the pacifier a crib or bed item
Start by keeping the pacifier out of daytime life. It stays in the crib or bed, and when your child wakes up it goes back there. Out of sight helps: keep spares in a drawer rather than in your bag or the car.
Step 2: Replace the moments it used to cover
HealthyChildren.org suggests keeping hands busy or offering a fun distraction when sucking is about boredom. For upset moments, try a cuddle, naming the feeling ("You're mad the tower fell") or a favorite stuffed animal. In the car, songs and a small toy can help.
Step 3: Drop naps, then bedtime
Once days are pacifier-free, stop offering it at naps. After a week or two, remove it at bedtime too. Many parents find bedtime is easiest last, because sleep pressure at night is stronger than at nap time.
Method 2: Cold turkey with a goodbye plan (best from about age 2)
Some toddlers do better with one clear change than with weeks of negotiating. Older toddlers and preschoolers who understand stories and rewards often respond well to a planned goodbye day.
- Talk about it ahead of time. A few days before, explain simply: "On Saturday, your pacifiers are going to the Paci Fairy, because you are getting so big." Picture books about giving up a pacifier can help.
- Let your child take part. Toddlers can gather the pacifiers into a box, leave them for the "Paci Fairy," mail them to a new baby, or trade them at the store for a new stuffed animal.
- Give something back. A new lovey, a special pillowcase or a small toy waiting in the morning fills the gap. Our guide to a toddler attached to a blanket explains why comfort objects are healthy.
- Use praise and a chart. HealthyChildren.org recommends praise, star charts and daily rewards, and the AAPD says positive rewards for each day without the pacifier work better than criticism or restraint.
- Remove every pacifier. Check the car, diaper bag and grandparents' house. A spare found on night three resets the whole process.
Getting through the first few nights
For many toddlers, the pacifier is a sleep cue, so bedtime is where weaning is hardest. Expect some protest, extra night waking or shorter naps at first. It usually eases as the new routine becomes familiar, as long as you stay consistent.
- Keep the rest of the bedtime routine exactly the same: bath, pajamas, books, song, lights out.
- Add a little extra connection at bedtime, such as one more book or a back rub, so the pacifier is replaced with comfort, not just removed.
- When your toddler wakes and asks for it, respond calmly and briefly with the same words each time: "The pacifiers went to the Paci Fairy. Here is your bunny."
- Use the same settling approach you would use for other night wakings. Our guide to helping a toddler self-soothe in the middle of the night has step-by-step ideas.
- Do not give the pacifier back after a hard night. Giving in once teaches your child that enough crying brings it back, which makes the next attempt harder.
When to talk with your pediatrician or dentist
Most toddlers give up the pacifier with nothing more than patience and a plan. The AAPD encourages a dental home by 12 months, partly so a dentist can guide families on ending sucking habits. Check in with your pediatrician or pediatric dentist if:
- Your child is approaching or past age 3 and still uses a pacifier for long periods.
- You notice the front teeth do not meet, the upper teeth are flaring forward, or the bite looks crooked.
- Your toddler has frequent ear infections.
- Weaning is causing distress that does not ease after a couple of weeks, or your child seems very anxious in other ways too.
- You have concerns about speech or language development.
Frequently asked questions
What age should a toddler stop using a pacifier?
The American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry recommends ending sucking habits by 36 months. It also notes that pacifier use after 12 months can raise the risk of ear infections and use beyond 18 months can affect the bite, so many families cut back to sleep-only use between 12 and 18 months and stop completely before age 3.
Is it better to wean from the pacifier gradually or cold turkey?
Both can work. Gradual weaning, limiting the pacifier to sleep times and then removing it, tends to suit younger toddlers. A planned cold-turkey day with a goodbye ritual and a reward often works well from about age 2, when children can understand a simple story. Whatever you choose, stay consistent.
How long does it take a toddler to stop asking for the pacifier?
It varies. Many toddlers protest for the first few nights and then settle as the new routine becomes familiar, especially when parents stay consistent and offer another comfort object. Children often take longer if weaning coincides with a big change such as a new sibling or starting daycare.
How do I get my toddler to sleep without a pacifier?
Keep the bedtime routine the same, add extra comfort such as another book or a back rub, give your child a lovey or stuffed animal, and respond to night waking briefly and calmly with the same words each time. Avoid handing the pacifier back after a hard night.
Does a pacifier cause speech delay?
The evidence is limited. The AAPD says the link to speech delay is weak, and a 2021 UK study of 100 children found most speech measures were unrelated to pacifier use, although frequent daytime use was associated with more atypical speech errors. Keeping the pacifier for sleep only is a sensible compromise.
Will my toddler start sucking their thumb after giving up the pacifier?
Some do. A Japanese study found that stopping a pacifier before 14 months was linked with more persistent finger sucking, which is one reason the AAPD suggests not forcing very early weaning. Offering a new comfort object and lots of reassurance helps.
Keep reading
Sources
This guide was checked against the current guidance below. Medical and safety recommendations can change; use the linked source and your child's clinician for decisions specific to your family.
- American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry: Policy on Pacifiers (revised 2024)
- HealthyChildren.org (AAP): Baby Pacifiers and Thumb Sucking: What Parents Need to Know
- Moon RY et al. Sleep-related infant deaths: updated 2022 recommendations for reducing infant deaths in the sleep environment. Pediatrics. 2022 (PMID 35726558)
- Niemelä M et al. Pacifier as a risk factor for acute otitis media: a randomized, controlled trial of parental counseling. Pediatrics. 2000 (PMID 10969091)
- Niemelä M et al. A pacifier increases the risk of recurrent acute otitis media in children in day care centers. Pediatrics. 1995 (PMID 7478830)
- Uhari M et al. A meta-analytic review of the risk factors for acute otitis media. Clin Infect Dis. 1996 (PMID 8783714)
- Fukumoto E et al. Cessation age of breast-feeding and pacifier use is associated with persistent finger-sucking. Pediatr Dent. 2013 (PMID 24553272)
- Strutt C et al. Does the duration and frequency of dummy (pacifier) use affect the development of speech? Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2021 (PMID 33939239)
- CDC: Botulism Prevention (honey and honey pacifiers)